Where did my YouTube Comments Go? (A Google+ Story)

Update: Google is shutting down Google+. After data breaches, low user numbers, and being put on the backburners of Google’s focus they’ve decided to terminate the social network.

Back when this post was written, (2013) YouTubers were required to make Google+ accounts. With this integration, comments came from the users Google+ account which more often than not showed the users real names. Changes were made back in 2017 to using the Youtubers comments rather than Google+ user profiles.

Using Google+ is now pretty much a mote point.

Now that the social sites shut down has been moved back from August to April of this year here are the things that you will see go away.

    • Private video sharing to G+ circles
    • Custom Google+ URLs for channels
    • Editing your channel’s icon and art on mobile
    • Linking to any Google+ profiles on channels
  • Commenting features on videos with an outdated YouTube mobile app (Versions from before September 2016)

end of the update-

Google made waves last week when they decided to make a big change to the social flow of the YouTube community.

As a company that thrives on YouTube, we were as surprised as you were when we logged in to find that our accounts HAD NO ACTIVITY.

No messages.

No comments on any of our videos. It was strange.

Then we found out what happened. Find out the wheres, whys, and hows to the Google+ takeover of YouTube comments.

Why did Google change YouTube comment policy?

According to Google’s announcement, the changes made were designed to reduce the anonymity of comments posted under a YouTube video.

Typically, any video that went viral brought with it a swarm of spam comments. These comments did everything from insult the creators of the original video to sell Converse shoes.

Google finally responded by changing the policy so a user had to be signed into a Google+ account in order to express said spam or verbal hate speech.

The new system was implemented without warning, and the public response, as expected, was not kind.

Without taking sides, let us analyze what is good and bad about the new change.

Why it should work

Google+ is a social platform, just like a Facebook or a Twitter.

Creating a Google+ account puts your unique face or brand on everything you type or share. That means that I am held directly accountable for everything that I post.

For shareholders, this is also a great thing.

Bringing the YouTube community further into the reaches of Google’s web (pun intended) is always good for advertising. It is possible that forcing Google+ use will make people more apt to embrace the “struggling platform” – despite low retention, Google+ does have hundreds of millions of “active” users.

Ideally, the move from anonymous commenting to required sign-in should spell the end of most spammy posts and lead to a more prosperous Google community.


Why Google+ comments do not work

The change has only brought MORE SPAM THAN BEFORE!

This makes some sense. Google created a monster by releasing the update so suddenly. This upset a lot of people – people who have been conditioned to not care about what is said on the Internet.

Spam accounts are still being created on the Google+ platform, just like Gmail and Facebook before it.

Google is also an unrestricted platform. Unlike a service like Twitter – which has a 140 character limit – people can post whatever they want in the new Google+ comments, including hashtags.

The other major issue with the comments system has nothing to do with the comments themselves, rather the management of said comments. A lot of businesses rely on marketing teams to check comments and respond.

This implementation adds one more place content managers have to look to get work done.

How do I check my YouTube comments?

Previously, to see your comments, you would go to the Video Manager on Google and then the “Inbox” section on the left.

This would break down into numerous sections, showing how many unread responses you had and letting you manage content directly under YouTube.

YouTube inbox

Now, this will no longer populate, and you will go to that bell icon on the top right of your screen:

Where comments go

This is the section devoted to Google+ notifications, and, since YouTube comments are now effectively managed through Google+, this is where they will go.

You could always go to https://plus.google.com/notifications/all to view a string of comments for posted videos, but this is less than perfect.

Widgets to the rescue

You can also go to the main dashboard of your YouTube account.

There, you will find a widget that displays all of your most recent comments.

If you click on the small settings button on the top right of the recent comments widget box, you can display up to 20 of the most recent comments.

Unless you have metric tons of subscribers (which is totally possible), being able to see up to the last 20 comments is usually enough.

Are Google+ notifications replacing YouTube comments a good thing?

Time will be the judge as people get more comfortable with the YouTube comments change.

So far, the reaction and implementation is more negative than positive.

What do you think about the changes made to the YouTube comments interface? Should they go back to the old way? Should they try something different?

Talk to us in the comments below, and subscribe to get access to member-exclusive deals.

2 thoughts on “Where did my YouTube Comments Go? (A Google+ Story)”

  1. As a screenreader, Youtube always seems to get vastly worse before it gets better, then it stays at a good point until Google or whoever owns it decides “NOPE! Let’s change everything again!”


    I rely heavily on comments to understand visual elements of videos I am watching, especially when it’s a performance like a Ted Talk or other “information dump for my brain/soul” type video. I should not have to jump through multiple hoops and use multiple platforms simultaneously to enjoy basic entertainment. Why couldn’t we offer the Google Plus version as a freaking OPTION, not “My way or … nope, not even the highway, get out!” approach that Google seems to always adopt with these system-wide changes?!

  2. November 2013???? !!! This has only just happened to my YouTube – what’s going on?

    I don’t know what the YouTube people think we users use comments for, but for example, I watch animal rescue videos, and when I want to know what the outcome was, I go to the comments and find out. If I’m watching a video about psychological problems, I want to know whether other people have found it useful, and if there is any feedback about where to go from there. I don’t see that I’m necessarily wanting to buy anything! I do, however, want to know how to correct this and go back to the original. And no more sudden changes, thank you!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.